Now that you have made all of those fine points, it is clear that you in no way understand Mr. Calhoun.
He was recognized by everyone in his time as being an outspoken, ardent supporter of the Constitution as well as states’ rights.
Nothing in your commentary would indicate that you have either read or absorbed anything that relates to that common understanding of his statesmanship.
But, that is your shortcoming, to which you are welcome to cling. So be it.
He writes the second worst tariff in American history, then complains when it's passed---called on his infantile bluff.
He advocates the Labor Theory of Value, which you are apparently utterly incapable of grasping, but which Owen, Marx, and Lenin all embraced as THE essential element of socialism and communism. Calhoun NEVER backed off of this---and thoroughly was supported by Fitzhugh.
Yeah, I've read ABSORBED, AND REJECTED this pre-Marxist Marxist destroyer of free speech. How about you?