Appeal Filed: Case No. 2012CV211398 DAVID FARRAR VS. BARACK OBAMA

SUPERIOR COURT, Fulton Co. Ga. ^ | 2/13/2012

[Elderberry]

I have not yet found a copy of the appeal.

[edge919]

Thanks for the update. The law is on the side of the appellants.

[philman_36]

@Chief Judge Cynthia D. Wright

One has to wonder if the Judge has a "particular side"?

[freebird5850]

I hope this is to overrule the issue of allowing Barry on the ballot?

[philman_36]

It’s a sad day in America when its Citizens have to start considering the political dispositions of their judges instead of simply taking in faith their dispositions regarding the law.

[edge919]

Right. They’re appealing Judge Malihi’s and Secretary of State Kemp’s infirm decision that Barry Soetoro is a natural-born citizen on the basis of dicta from an Indiana Appeals Court that never actually declared Obama to be a natural-born citizen.

[FroggyTheGremlim]

What kind of ruling would favor the side that ignored subpoenas and didn't even show up?

It would seem that the appeal is a no brainer.

But this is not the America I grew up in.

[philman_36]

They’re appealing Judge Malihi’s and Secretary of State Kemp’s infirm decision that Barry Soetoro is a natural-born citizen on the basis of dicta from an Indiana Appeals Court that never actually declared Obama to be a natural-born citizen.
Shouldn't you wait to read the appeal before stating that?
Or have you already read the appeal elsewhere?

[Cletus.D.Yokel]

Appointed by and Chief Legal Counsel to...

Governor Zell Miller.

Makes for an interesting twist.

[philman_36]

Apparently Miller appointed Malihi, the first judge, as well.

[danamco]

Ping!

[Cletus.D.Yokel]

As CLC, she would vet Miller’s positions during campaigns and policy discussions. Miller, as I recall was quite conservative for a D and equally as patriotic.

[simplesimon]

Ping ~!

[Harlan1196]

The judge offered the plaintiffs a default judgment that would have recommended that Obama be off the ballot.

The plaintiffs REJECTED the default judgment and requested that the case be decided solely on the merits of their arguments and evidence.

The judge rejected their arguments and evidence.

They had victory in their hands and threw it away.

[FroggyTheGremlim]

"The judge offered the plaintiffs a default judgment "

Sorry, I didn't know that.

Stupid.

[edge919]

Shouldn't you wait to read the appeal before stating that? Or have you already read the appeal elsewhere?

Learn to read. I didn't say what the basis of the appeal was. I gave the basis of the ALJ's and SoS's decision.

[edge919]

The judge offered the plaintiffs a default judgment that would have recommended that Obama be off the ballot.

There's nothing to indicate the judge was actually going to issue a default judgment. The plaintiffs did NOT says they wanted the case to be decided ONLY on their arguments and evidence.

[lula]

They wanted the information and evidence to be a matter of record. It wasn’t stupid. There are many questions in those documents and the judge just passed the buck, or was gotten to by the powers that be.

[Harlan1196]

This is what the judge said:

“Ordinarily, the Court would enter a default order against a party that fails to participate in any stage of a
proceeding. Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. 616-1-2-.30(1) and (5). Nonetheless, despite the Defendant's failure to appear, Plaintiffs asked this Court to decide the case on the merits
of their arguments and evidence. The Court granted Plaintiffs’ request.”

The issue is that their evidence made Obama’s case for him. Obama would have agreed with everything Irion and Hatfield said about him - yes, in fact Obama senior was not a US citizen. What the judge rejected was the “two citizen parents = NBC” argument. And that the judge decided on by researching pertinent case law as he was entitled to do.