[Talisker]

How is it elitist? Neither she nor her kids are Jewish. There’s nothing to accept.

So you're saying Judaism is purely racial? That there is no such thing as religious Jewish conversion?

Then why call it a religion?

Why not just designate it as a race?

[SJackson]

So you're saying Judaism is purely racial? That there is no such thing as religious Jewish conversion?

Of course there is. Hopefully Gwyneth will avail herself of that for her children, even herself. If she rejects conversion, that's her choice as well.

[Poison Pill]

So you're saying Judaism is purely racial?

I never said any such thing. There are 2 ways to be considered a Jew. 1) You're mother is Jewish. 2) You convert. Neither Paltrow nor her kids qualify on either account.