Grossly misleading? The distinction is no different than saying that some people who get food stamps have paid taxes in the past, while others get food stamps without having paid taxes (or as much in taxes). It is all just an income transfer. The whole system is intergenerational theft.
WARNING - It sounds as if you pay taxes. The content of this link has caused suicidal / homicidal urges in other taxpayers that have seen it. Avoid having sharp objects or deadly weapons nearby.