How is it different? Both are belief systems. Both believe in a higher power.
It may come as a shock to you but only 1/3rd of the world population are Christians. About 1/5th are Islam. So nearly 50% of the human population on this planet do not believe in any of the Abrahamic religions.
She renounced witchcraft. Good for her.
My point is that you claim Wicca is just another religion. Like it has been accepted by the culture as a whole.
It is political poison, as it should be. If you think people would have no issues with someone who had not renounced witchcraft, having a first date on a Satanic altar, I think you are very, very uninformed.
And if you think America has completely lost its Judeo-Christian moorings, we better both pray to God you are wrong. Because then, America is over.