As far as creepiness, the latest one I watched was "Quarantine"
Didn’t see “Quarantine”—was it good?
The last disturbing movie my wife and I watched togeter, “30 Days of Night.” What a terrifying movie. Very well done, but I had a hard time sleeping that night, and it stuck in my head for days.
As good as it was, I really have no desire to see it again any time soon.