[shadowland]

“How can you penalize 2 USA Citizen for serving their country?”

My whole point was that could not have been the intent of the founders.

[Las Vegas Ron]

My whole point was that could not have been the intent of the founders.

This is an outstanding thread and has some great historical references from the Founders on this subject. It's long but a great study.

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-bloggers/2450158/posts

[rxsid]

"How can you penalize 2 USA Citizen for serving their country?”

My whole point was that could not have been the intent of the founders."

---------------------------------------------------

It wasn't their intent. And, Vattel accounts for that situation. See here.