Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: betty boop
"Do you believe that logic is a spontaneous production of matter?

Logic is a construction of the mind which is used to determine and order truth and information into knowledge and then to understanding and creative acts. The mind is a physical machine which supports the functions of sentience and rationality. W/o that physical machinery, there can be no instance of mind and thus no instance of logic.

It is notable that the universe itself is logical. That is, it is completely consistent, otherwise one could find and observe instances of A≠A in reality.

"Why is the universe intelligible?"

Intelligibility is a property of things which have properties that enable observability and which are logically consistent. All instances of any physical object has properties which allow those objects to interact with other physical objects. That interaction is a sensing process. The universe is intelligible, because all forms of energy that exist in it have properties which determine the nature of interaction(the sense/relationship process) and are logically consistent.

"how did it acquire that property?"

Fundamental physical objects do not aquire their properties, or essence. Their properties/essence is inherent in every instance of the object as long as the object is an instance of that particular form. ie. a photon does not aquire it's properties.

"How did man acquire the property of intelligence, which is the key to knowledge of the intelligible order of the universe? " The intelligible order of the universe exists independently whether any instance of an intellignet being exists, or not. It is as given above. The properties of the forms of energy that exist in this universe are what allow and provide for the evolutionary process that results in mind/man.

Again, there is Epicurus principle, which says keep every theory consistent with the facts. The properties of the stuff that provides for intelligibility, also provides for sentient rational mind that would arise from. That's deterministic. Epicurus principle and the instance of a sentient rational mind provides for freedom of choice.

630 posted on 03/29/2010 10:34:53 AM PDT by spunkets
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 628 | View Replies ]


To: spunkets; Alamo-Girl; Quix; kosta50; metmom; wmfights; P-Marlowe; shibumi; xzins; MHGinTN; ...
Their properties/essence is inherent in every instance of the object as long as the object is an instance of that particular form.

How does an object acquire its particular form?

You aver much without providing much evidence. E.g., "The mind is a physical machine which supports the functions of sentience and rationality. W/o that physical machinery, there can be no instance of mind and thus no instance of logic."

What is your evidence for the statement "the mind is a physical machine?" How does something physical acquire a mind — what is the natural process for this? Is mind innate to a material particle?

Yours sounds like just another "just-so" story to me, spunkets.

631 posted on 03/29/2010 10:52:02 AM PDT by betty boop (The personal is not the public's business. See: the Ninth Amendment.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 630 | View Replies ]

To: spunkets; betty boop
The mind is a physical machine which supports the functions of sentience and rationality. W/o that physical machinery, there can be no instance of mind and thus no instance of logic.

The brain is a machine. The mind is something far different. What is the mind and where did it and intelligence come from if not from other intelligence?

If you are claiming that intelligence is a byproduct of certain natural forces which came together at random, you have nothing on which to base that.

Intelligibility is a property of things which have properties that enable observability and which are logically consistent. All instances of any physical object has properties which allow those objects to interact with other physical objects. That interaction is a sensing process. The universe is intelligible, because all forms of energy that exist in it have properties which determine the nature of interaction(the sense/relationship process) and are logically consistent.

What ARE you smoking?

633 posted on 03/29/2010 11:09:03 AM PDT by metmom (Welfare was never meant to be a career choice.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 630 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson