[americanophile]

I have no idea why I was pinged...though I must say I completely disagree that a Christmas tree is ‘patent idolatry,’ it’s manifestly absurd, since I’ve never heard of anyone worshipping their tree, or giving it offerings, or anything of the kind as you suggest.

[TNdandelion]

I don't consider my decorated tree an "idol" but I also don't put anything religious (stars, angels, etc) on it. But I can certainly see how someone else could view it as such if the tree was decorated with religious symbolism. I know many christians who believe that the religious celebration of Christmas is sinful because it is an institution of man rather than of God. Something about men not having the authority to add to the bible.

I can see both sides. I believe that the Christmasteers have good intentions with their tradition but I wouldn't question the faith and discipline of those that choose not to take such liberties.