The Judgement says:
Keyes may have standing.
This Court can’t deselect a sitting President.
If the case had been file before Obama elected then Carter may have been able to offer redress.
Case filed late because of KREEPs delaying/disagreement.
Carter points to action of Quo Warranto in the DC Court as the only Judicial way to remove a sitting President.
Still no hearin of the actual merits of the case, ie is Obama a NBC.
No, that's not what he said. He said the only place for a Quo Warranto application to be heard is in the DC circuit, and he's right. He made no comment on the likelihood of it's success or even it's applicability. He dismissed solely because of venue, nothing more and nothing less.