It seems terribly odd to me that some people hold a position that a foreign nation's whims of law determine who the United States can or cannot consider a natural born citizen.
Orly Taitz was just on with Joy Behar on CNN HL. Y’all missed it. :)
That said, I'll reiterate that, under every plausibly authoritative source I've encountered you are a natural-born citizen, born of the soil and of two citizen parents.
That Italian birthright citizenship under jus sanguinis might some authorities pause, though.