You are both a little short sighted on what we are after.
So I ask again:
Do you care that Barry O. has had his entire record of life activity lost or sealed and does his unexamined life arouse any curiousity in you?
I'm unaware of any Constitutional requirement that says my curiosity has to be satisfied before someone can be president. If I have my doubts about a candidate then I don't vote for him, but that's about the extent of what I'm entitled to.