Wrong. Cott Shop was responding to Buck W.’s extended multi-reply diatribe about how Catholics are the “real” Christians, whereas bible-believing creationists are supposedly “phony” (all the while refusing to profess Jesus Christ as his Lord and Savior, or to answer the question as to whether he is even Catholic!).
So CS doesn’t really believe the embarrassingly bigoted trash that appears on the site that he linked to?
That must be the conversation you're having in your head, because he hasn't said anything like that here. He's called certain individuals phonies, but not a whole denomination.