Terrorists have planted a WMD upwind of your family. It goes off in one hour. The situation makes evacuation impossible.
The FBI has one of the bombers but he’s not talking.
What do you do?
We have a constitution in this country. If you really believe that scenario will happen (it wasn’t the case in any of the waterboarding sitautions) then you need to give Obama the power via constituional amendment to authorize the torture of American citizens. The constitution is very clear on this.