It's a straw man at best...there are much better arguments out there, that Obama is beginning to show all by himself (cabinet selections, abortion, idiotic press secretaries, speaking with Hamas instead of Israel, picking a fight with Rush....all this in just his FIRST week)...that'll compel America to reject this false Messiah come 2012 (and will emasculate his power in 2010 to start)...
Do NOT say this is for getting Obama to prove his eligibility in 2012. Say that this is to close a loop hole and to protect our Federation.