Nah, jail the criminals and send the others back to where they came from. Only, seal the borders first. I’m not vindictive, just fed up with their in-your-face attitude toward we citizens.
Where does that attitude come from? It comes from the fact that they think they are above the law. And, in a way they are. The tacit acceptance of their presence by the U.S. govt. gives them the idea that they are not culpable for their crime of being an invader and it escalates from there.