Eagle Eye was good.
An American Carol fell flat. It was funny in spots, but that was it. It seemed kind of blah.
That was my impression of it as well. I thought is was watchable, but definitely not something I would tell people to go out of their way to see. The only time I could ever see myself watching it again is if it is on cable sometime in the future and there is nothing else on. In my opinion, it was a very concept but it could have been much, much better.