[Vicki]

No doubt about it McCain won. Obama exposed for the empty suit he is.

[StarFan]

Nina Easton thinks McCain knocked Obama off balance with his jabs at the beginning. Obama comes off as "policy speak and not direct" says Nina, whatever that means. Fred said McCain came off very strong at the end. Brit mentioned how often Obama said he 'agreed with Sen. McCain' and of course Juan thought Obama put McCain on the defensive and did well when discussing the economy. On foreign policy he gives it to McCain

All discussed Obama's smirking which didn't play well.