[Girlene]

And what exactly went to far?

Joking about Todd Palin having relations with his daughter. It's crude. Sometimes the end doesn't justify the means. This is one of those times. It's called having a conscious. I don't laugh about the allegation of a girl being abused (the means) even if I agree the NYT or Daily Kos have gone too far in their allegations about Palin and her family(the end). That's just me.

[tioga]

-there are a significant number of women who were abused as young girls.......this is another one of those issues best left alone. Much like the Down’s Syndrome baby. It was crude and pointless. The only purpose was to slam the Palins....as that is what happened and all anyone will remember — “those Alaskans......not like us, did you hear? Incest. Psst, pass it on....” — I doubt the charge will stick against the NYTimes at all. It should, but it won't. I just don't watch that tripe.