Which results in the better tool?
For we are talking about science and the purpose of Science is to develop tools to make our world better. Which Flu vaccines should be made this year? How will we treat various Cancers in 5 years? etc. What may or may not of happened thousands of years ago is a Philosophical debate.
==Which results in the better tool?
Creation/ID science is a far better tool to make our world better, especially when it comes to treating disease. After all, evolutionary biology is wedded to the notion of random mutation, whereas Creation/ID, while allowing for limited random mutation, also posits directed mutation. And as the field of epigenetics is increasingly making clear, science would have been a lot better off if we had allowed these two conceptions to compete for funding (not to mention space in the mainstream science journals).