That's why I said that your argument is akin to saying that since the molecular configuration of the universe can never be identical, that it can't rain.
That's why I said that your argument is akin to saying that since the molecular configuration of the universe can never be identical, that it can't rain.
Whether it's raining or not is the output. That has nothing to do with the point I'm trying to make, which has to do with the input.
You're saying, if I'm understanding correctly, that the proof that the mind has a non-material component is that the same input to two minds can have different outputs.
What I'm saying is that the experience that a person has is also part of the set of input. Experiences differs from person to person and cannot be controlled for. Therefore the differences in the output may be attributable to the uncontrollable part of the input, whether or not there is a non-material component to the mind.