Posted on 06/07/2008 6:52:20 AM PDT by do the dhue
The People
The Problem
The "Death Tax" does do this, somewhat. I used to be under the assumption that the death tax was inherently wrong, but now I see that was an incorrect assumption.
It can be wrong, if it is employed merely as an additional revenue generating tool, or as a way of controlling social policy, etc.
But if we view tax as something close to merely a reflection of the benefits gained by an individual by having the government versus anarchy, then it can be seen that those with wealth benefit far more from the institution of government than someone who does not. (An anarchic system would be very vulnerable to brigandry, and there's no way the stock market could exist to allow individuals so many paper billions of dollars.)
Real Property taxes are another, yet they hit only one segment of wealth.
It's a difficult question, but I believe it is important to understanding the wealth gap--a phenomenon that has brought about the downfall of civilizations throughout history, even today. I believe we have restistances to its effects, but we are not immune.
It's a shame that so many so-called conservatives have forgotten that voice.
I don't know that Baldwin has that same understanding or experience. Besides, the Constitution Party jumped the shark a while ago. I say this as a one-time ardent supporter.
Your use of the word “we” is curious. Do you believe the collective should make these decisions or should the owners of the resources be free to trade with the consumers of the resources?
Changing the subject, eh? I thought we were talking about public, not private.
I thought we had exhausted the subject, just like the soil if you mine it growing crops.
And no, the subject was using oil inside the borders of the US. Much if which is privately owned. And the rest which is currently owned by the collective should be auctioned off to the highest bidder.
You dragged the conversation into agriculture but ignored the rest of my post. Should we conserve our reserves of iron ore and let others deplete theirs first? Or copper, or uranium? All the minerals we mine inside our borders?
Why? is this a protection racket?
Already finished ;)
Hope that more people will read your post today--probably when they should be working--Col. Riley's site is a very interesting visit.
Cheers!
Thanks for the exchange. I wish someone with your thoughts were running for President. The growing wealth/income disparity could be just the slow boiling water for the US. Some think we should be a pure textbook economy but we are a political economy with the overtones that voting implies. A gated community around dollars has joined the gated community around real estate awaiting the eventual surge of the serfs. But to what end considering the liquidity of $? The balance of government conceived by the Founding Fathers needs to be applied to the economic world for the long range good of America.
McBush and Hussein Obama are of one voice on amnesty for illegals. Search for “SECRETS in McCAIN’s AMNESTY bill” on Y**Tube for a start...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.