Posted on 05/27/2008 8:54:31 AM PDT by wsjreader
Considering his family’s communist history, his uncle may have fought with the Red Army.
If there was an uncle, it could have been the brother of one of Obama’s grandparents. It seems unlikely that a contemporary of his mother would have fought in WWII since she was born in 1942.
The truth is more likely that his great uncle was in a unit that helped liberate Dachau. Obama is just too historically illiterate to know the truth. I’d still say it is 60-40 that there was no uncle and it was just a story he heard somewhere.
free dixie,sw
Maybe he will have to trot out his “typical white person” grandma (pull her out from under the wheels of the bus) to explain just which relative was at the liberation of Auschwitz. Maybe the uncle that served in the Red Army.....
He has no uncles. He has cousins.
What a lying commie sack!
It does say a great deal about his character to exploit a lie (or a “legend”) for political gain. He’s using this story as a way to gain even more points with the anti-war crowd.
I argued with a liberal at a volleyball game yesterday about this very thing...well it started out with this particular subject, anyway.
Her whine was “war produces more casualties than what we really know about”. She went on to talk about soldiers “coming back from VN and Iraq” and “all the suicides you don’t hear about” and how the “largest percentage of homeless people are veterans”. We even argued about oil companies and the price of oil, drilling in Alaska, George Bush, etc. I think we covered it all. I was pretty well exhausted when I left her and was polite and even said “good-bye” and “good luck” to her girls in volleyball. (My 2 girls creamed her 3 girls in a match, btw.)
I told her I “understand your position tho I disagree” and that “you can’t help it because you’re a liberal and that’s just what you believe.” I guess that was too personal.
All I got was a dirty look when we parted. sigh
I need to really be more prepared when I get into these discussions or don’t get into them. I always walk away from them thinking “damn, I shoulda said *this* or *that*”
I posted several weeks ago that Obama beat the Clintons by out-lying them. The other thing which accounts for his victory is that the Clintons aren’t as far left, which infuriates the hard-core Demonrat base.
The Great Uncle was inducted in 1942 his name was Ralph Waldo Emerson Dunham, :
http://www.kshs.org/genealogists/military/wwiiveteransresults.php?page=364&branch=A
He was inducted into the Army, but there is no mention of what Division he served in.
“Was his uncle a Soviet!?”
Where was Frank Marshall Davis during WW II?
http://www.aim.org/aim-column/obamas-communist-mentor/
All of his relatives from Kenya volunteered to join the Soviet army in WW2.
Obama’s telling the truth.
Obama also claimed that his grandfather marched with Patton.
I am just suprised that there is no protest from the Jewish organizations.
In Selma, with Dr. King?
Oh, it will come. Not from the liberal organisations like ADF, but the Zionist and Conservatives will certainly say a word or two.
I expect something from Eli Wiesel or David Horowitz.
Great uncle called "uncle" makes sense - I always called my great-uncles "uncle".
Should be possible to track down his military record.
No way he liberated Auschwitz, maybe Dachau?
Hillary, nee Hildegarde, can beat this Holocaust claim. After all, she was born in the waning days of WWII, under Allied bombardment inside an underground Berlin bunker, to Eva Braun.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.