What exactly is your point? That something that is a theory is not credible?
I suppose you are aware of the theory of gravity? Some call it a law of gravity. But no one really knows what gravity is so it is best catagorized as a theory.
So you are saying that gene changes causing phenotypic traits that lead to superior reproduction probabilities do not lead to the generation of like kind that carry that genetic trait? Do you need an explanation about what constitutes superior reproduction probabilities?
Give me reason to believe your "theory". I understand the premise. Tell me how life starts! How can it change, from inert matter into life form with the ability to reproduce itself. Provide a good hypothesis. Then I may get on board your ideas...
Until you get your answer, I can refer you to Genesis 1 and take you through the Book of Revelations. It offers a better explanation than I have seen elsewhere... and it's a whole lot more believable than the EVO Liturgy, and it's apologists.