I live in CA, so my vote will go to whom I think should be president. Although when it comes down to that choice (for you swing states), I say you go Republican...unless it’s Rudy.
If it’s Rudy, then our party is going to be hammered. Anyone else, is ten times better than Hillary.
Here’s how I would Rank things.
Hillary 0
Rudy 1
McCain 2
Huckabee 3
Romney 4
Fred/Hunter 8
Perfection doesn’t exist, imo.
Hillary 0
Rudy 1
McCain 2
Huckabee 3
Romney 4
Fred/Hunter 8
I would change the McCain number to 3 and Huckabee to 2. Also I would give Romney a 6. Otherwise your list is perfect.