[valkyry1]

bsharp, his ‘strawman version of abiogenesis’ as you refer to it, is more plausible than your ‘scientific version of abiogenesis’ or as you say, ‘imperfectly self replicating molecule... subject to some time consistent selection’.

So many myths in evolution, one being the imperfectly self replicating molecule... subject to some time consistent selection’ arising up out of the morass.

Pray tell sharp, just what molecules can come about except as results of other chemical exchanges?

We will start off real simple, H and O² for starters

[b_sharp]

" So many myths in evolution, one being the imperfectly self replicating molecule... subject to some time consistent selection’ arising up out of the morass.

"Pray tell sharp, just what molecules can come about except as results of other chemical exchanges?

"We will start off real simple, H and O2 for starters

Are you sure you want to do this?

Where did I claim that molecules come about by anything other than chemical reactions?