[Corin Stormhands]

Why would I need to read the books when I’ve seen the movies?

I give up.

[PetroniusMaximus]

“I give up.”

We’re not talking about great literature here. A book - a movie, big difference. I’m sure if the differences were that big there would be a general outcry on the part of the Potterheads.

[Pistolshot]

Why would I need to read the books when I’ve seen the movies?

I give up.

Well, at least he's honest about his ignorance. And he still didn't answer this one.

Here's a 'what if' for you. What if your children were REQUIRED to read the HP books as part of a lesson on occultism in society? Would you allow that?