Posted on 06/25/2007 8:27:31 AM PDT by SwinneySwitch
Activists say public isn't only culprit — leaders and companies are also culpable
MEXICO CITY — Mexicans have become world-class litterbugs.
Soft drink bottles, snack wrappers, used diapers and cigarette butts clog city streets, rural highways and scenic beaches. Mountains of garbage stand sentry-like in empty lots and at the edges of bucolic rural villages. Discarded plastic bags hang in trees and dangle from cactus like bitter industrial fruit.
Not every Mexican litters, of course. And perhaps no one does so all the time. But enough of them do, enough of the time, that this nation of 105 million people is choking on its refuse.
Yet, there has been no concerted long-term anti-litter campaign. Only a smattering of Mexican towns and cities have municipal garbage dumps.
For many environmentalists, litter takes a backseat to fouled water, dirty air, coastline overbuilding, widespread deforestation and severe soil erosion. To many citizens, litter is all but invisible. And in the view of some observers, there is a lack of public responsibility.
"People see it as a problem that doesn't affect them, but it does," said Francisco Padron, director of a Mexico City civic organization aimed at educating the public on environmental issues.
Consider just a few impacts:
• Litter contributes to severe flooding in Mexico City every rainy season, which is beginning now, when discarded bottles and other trash clog storm drains. Each year the city government makes a plea to end the littering. And each year that plea is uniformly ignored. • "Uncleanliness" — primarily litter — ranks first among the complaints of foreign tourists visiting Mexico, according to studies conducted by the Tourism Ministry. • Haphazard roadside dumps serve as breeding grounds for mosquitoes, contributing to the outbreak of dengue fever and other diseases in rural southern villages. Environmentalists blame a lack of government programs and corporate interest for much of the problem.
Fines for littering are rare and even more rarely enforced. Few cities or towns bother to put trash cans in the streets. Even where public trash cans do exist, they're seldom emptied.
Mexican environmental officials say that only several dozen of Mexico's more than 2,500 cities, towns and villages have a landfill or other kind of municipal garbage dump.
"There is a lack of political will," said Jorge Trevino, director of ECOCE (Ecología y Compromiso Empresarial), an industry-funded group that manages recycling and public awareness campaigns. "There is a lack of infrastructure. In many cities, there is a lack of planning. There is nowhere to put the trash."
But there's also a lack of public concern or responsibility, Trevino and other activists say.
People tuck pop bottles into hedges, trees and lampposts. Schoolchildren drop snack packages wherever they please. Drivers of intercity buses instruct passengers to toss refuse out the windows rather than leave it aboard.
There's also little downside, either legal or social, for the litterers.
"In the United States, you have an authority that is watching. Here in Mexico, there is nothing like that," Trevino said. "If you throw trash on the highway here in Mexico, no one says anything."
Like many of its social problems, Mexico's litter epidemic may be anchored in a deeply entrenched political system in which citizen input has been discouraged.
Not 'their' problem Trash pickup in Mexico City and other urban centers has been free and largely controlled by labor unions, said Hector Castillo, a sociologist who studies the refuse industry at Mexico's National Autonomous University. Many Mexicans consider trash, including litter, to be somebody else's problem. "They throw trash in the street because that's why they pay taxes," Castillo said. "Somebody else picks it up."
Litter has become a global problem, of course. But societies like Mexico's, whose exploding and still-poor populations crowd into cities and consume packaged food rather than what they produce themselves, suffer the most from it.
"There has been a more dramatic change in the types of waste we are producing than in the culture of disposing of that waste," said Padron, the Mexico City environmentalist. "Trash has been seen only as waste and not as valuable material that can be recycled."
Padron and other activists say corporations have an obligation to figure out how to dispose of packaging.
"In a responsible economy, they have the responsibility for what happens to their wastes," Padron said.
Mexico has yet to experience a watershed moment that brings litter to the forefront of public consciousness, environmentalists say. And anti-litter efforts must be intense, sustained and widespread to be effective. Even then, there are no guarantees.
Don't Mess With Mexico The Don't Mess With Texas campaign, run by the state's Department of Transportation, is considered one of the more successful in the United States. Texas officials say the amount of litter has been reduced by as much as a third since the start of this decade. Still, telephone surveys indicate that as many as 77 percent of Texans under the age of 25 admit to littering, and 55 percent of all Texans say they do.
ECOCE, Trevino's organization, began a television ad campaign several years ago aimed at shaming the public into taking care of trash.
Dubbed "no manches," which can loosely translate to "don't mess with," the effort featured children chastising people for tossing trash.
The ads, which had little apparent impact on public actions, have been discontinued for other campaigns.
"The trouble is, we're the only ones doing this sort of thing," Trevino said.
Still, there are some hopeful signs in Mexico.
A tiny market for recycled plastic bottles is growing, with most of the recovered plastic shipped to the United States and China for further processing.
Two years ago, ecotourism guides and a television network raised a ruckus about the trash clogging the Grijalva River inside the stunning Sumidero Canyon of the southernmost state of Chiapas.
Local, state and federal officials mobilized an army of workers to clean up the mess. More than 1,200 tons of garbage were collected from the narrow gorge in a few weeks. The officials claimed victory.
Today, news reports portray the river through the canyon as trashed out as ever.
"It's a war without end," said Marlene Ehrenberg, the Mexico City tour guide and environmentalist who first raised the alarm about the Sumidero.
"I'm so tired and fed up," she said.
dudley.althaus@chron.com
We need to send the Native American on the Horse with tear rolling down his cheek to Mexico.
Yes, I have thought about that a lot. We could appoint someone to be Judge Advocate or something to that effect like they did in Japan after the war.
We take over their oil reserves and then set the oil royalties up like they are in Alaska, where the citizens get some of the revenue.
We might be surprised how many of them would return to their homeland.
From South Texas Lady who resides close to Laredo Texas
This appears to be a cultural issue. The trouble with our neighbors coming in to live in our neighborhood (the U.S.)is that they bring their ‘traditions’ with them. That is okay for the most part but as stated in the article this attitude of ... “They throw trash in the street because that’s why they pay taxes,” Castillo said. “Somebody else picks it up,” seems to be taking hold here in the U.S. too.
[sigh]
Iron Eyes Cody is as big a phony as Jorge W. Arbusto.
Another job Mexicans won’t do.
As for the disgusting habits; they let their kids just do their thing naturally in the asles of Walmart and just leave it there. They also open packages of diapers and use them without paying for them.
What a polite way to say that they're pigs.
The real question is why do you support someone (Jorge W. Arbusto) who cares more about Mexican illegal aliens than he does about American citizens?
Here in GA the trash on the highways has increased several fold along with the Mexican "guest workers" of Jorje Bush. Though to give them there due, there are probably about 100 times as many Mexicans here as there were 20 years ago, and the trash levels are up less than 10 fold.
Darn Dollar Store reading glasses.
I thought the 25 was unbelievably bad, the 55 is just wild.
Thanks for the polite update.
They replaced the "Drive Friendly" signs with "Don't mess with Texas" signs. Texas is now a little cleaner and has a lot more unfriendly drivers.
America, 2050. Thanks, George.
Thanks for your post.
It gives me no pleasure to post what I did, but DAMN! Why is President Bush caving into all these stupid liberals? I hope he wakes up and straightens out!!!
Or the way some people pull their car up in front of your well maintained home and empty out the trash, including dirty diapers
Mexico, Jamaica, Haiti....corruption run amok.
“Litter choking streets throughout Mexico’
The same would be true of East St Louis, but how can you tell?
I have never heard of that one.
Yes, the other favorite spot to dump dirty diapers is the grocery store parking lot. My experience in LA anyway. One night while waiting in line to pay for groceries, I noticed a smell and looking down, there was a growing puddle. The woman in front of us was urinating while paying for groceries. Looking at my wife and I , she says, “When I’m in a tight, I’m in a tight”.
“They throw trash in the street because that’s why they pay taxes,” Castillo said. “Somebody else picks it up.”
Next time you’re in, say, a Burger King, try this little experiment in ethnography.
Pay attention to which minority cleans up their table before they leave. Who leaves their trash behind for others to deal with? Hint: it won’t be the Latinos.
Now ask yourself how failing to be responsible for one’s own detritus manifests in other ways, and where the fault lies.
At the beach, you find them in toilets and urinals.
Same situation in Sacramento. If you ride Amtrak east, you go through miles of trash left by “the homeless”. Actually the RR will clean it up and in months, thanks to the liberal policies of CA, it’s as bad as ever. Then they spend millions on a bike trail and allow the “homeless” (aka America’s Most Wanted) to camp out on it.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.