[hosepipe]

[.. WHAT DID I MISS? ..]
[.. Puppies aren’t muffins, so muslims aren’t muslims and christians aren’t christians. Got it. ..]

NO.... SOME muslims are not muslims and SOME christians are not christians..

Heck SOME republicans are not republicans.. (RINOS)..

[tacticalogic]

Heck SOME republicans are not republicans.. (RINOS)..

That would be "some Republicans are not republicans".

When you say "some muslims are not muslims" does the word "muslim" have the same meaning in both instances? If so, then it is self-contradictory. If not then it is sophistry.