Wielding the broad brush today?
Before answering your question, tacticalogic, I thought I'd stroll over to Darwin Central to see what, if anything, they were saying about our recent exchanges -- yours, Stultis', and mine. And they are in full cry, doing just what I suggested Neo-Darwinists routinely do as a matter of M.O.: Trash the opponent rather than engage the argument. But then, that's a whole lot of trouble, because you have to understand the argument first.
They're not only trashing me personally, but also editor-surveyor and metmom; GodGunsGuts; others....
Jeepers, I think these people really need to get a life!
And so I'd have to say: No, I'm not painting with too broad a brush here....