You wrote: “Who decided that the two were mutually exclusive?
When you think about it, Christianity itself evolved.”
Wrong. The Theory of Evolution, to the extent it includes belief that humans evolved from earlier forms of primates, is absolutely contrary to Christianity. In fact, if man descended from earlier primates, Christianity is disproved.
You mean that if allele frequencies change over time, then Jesus didn't die on the Cross? I don't profess to be an expert in Christian theology (it's not my religion, first of all), but I'm not sure I follow your reasoning.