[Michael.SF.]

I propose the third method should be the elimination of the "government rent".

How would you then propose we pay for basic services that are currently paid (in many states) through property tax?

I would assume that you would have an alternative.

I for one do not mind paying a fair and reasonable tax on purchases, including property. What I do mind is a graduated income tax that punishes my success, while allowing those of low income to receive money, from me, due to their position in life (it is OK that they pay zero on income, but no 'tax credits').

I do mind that I do not get a fair return on my tax invested. Thus when bridge tolls double in five years, while gas tax goes into the general fund, I feel I have a right to complain.

[ChildOfThe60s]

How would you then propose we pay for basic services that are currently paid (in many states) through property tax?

That is a fair and reasonable question. It has to be addressed, obviously. But (again my fantasy) in my opinion that should be decided after we determine what really are basic services. Right now, basic services are any damn thing they decide they want to spend money on. And nothing is ever a one time expenditure. "What were once luxuries are now necessities". The unwritten motto of government.

[kddid]

Yes, what are basic services? A vague description to say the least. I'm sure these "basic services" include a myriad of welfare programs that could be better addressed in the private sector or through charities. And let's not forget the many bureaucracies that have been created to administer those funds.