“She admitted it after the fact”
So what?
“they have no idea when they claim You downloaded a song illegally of knowing if you own that song or not legally.”
When you show proof of your use rights I guess they will know you have a legal right.
This assumes guilt from the get go, entire presumption of innocence is out the door, which is exactly where the RIAA and the MPAA both are at.
I know I get some letter from someone saying pay me, I’ll tell em to get bent. They want to sue me in civil court, I’ll countersue for harrassment. Of course this is why they pick on 20somethings with no resources or knowledge of the law instead of adults who would take them to the cleaners.