You're just too sophisticated for the rest of us rubes, apparently. I guess we're supposed to ignore the fact that Rudy supported Clinton's veto of a PBA abortion ban - one that provided exceptions for the life of the mother. Yep, ignore what a politician has done, and cynically accept what a politician says now that he needs our vote.
Guys like you are exhibit "A" of what is wrong with politics today. You ridicule people for displays of common sense.
I cannot think of a politician I have supported that I agree with 100 percent of the time. In fact, Fred Thompson co-sponsored McCain-Feingold. So there are likely to be lots of things in a candidate's past that various people are going to disagree with.
Now I could easily try to get you to support Rudy by trashing Thompson on McCain-Feingold, hammering it at you day after day after day. But it wouldn't work any more than your attempting to trash Giuliani with this or that position. It's all inside baseball stuff and will make absolutely no difference to anyone who is undecided.
Rudy Giuliani is a hero. Now, he may or may not actually BE a hero. But the American people think he is a hero because they saw it on television. That makes the guy imminently electable. His electability is the wind driving his popularity, and that will not be compromised by whatever minutae you wish to expose about him.
These attacks on Giuliani from the right just solidify his support among crossovers. The more crossovers like him, the better his numbers get (in a general election matchup), and the more likely he will win the nomination.