[SampleMan]

It appears that an assumption is being made that Giuliani will actually keep all the Red states. That assumption should not be made at this point in time.

Precisely. The argument that he would capture some blue states is a head scratcher. Under that argument the GOP should run Hillary, then they could capture ALL the blue states.

[Nonstatist]

Which red state would Guliani lose? (Especially if he picks a mainstream Pubbie VP)