> I'm not sure what I said that would indicate that's how I feel.
The fact that, in your view, what makes an idol is the significance you, personally, give to the item.
That's not the way the rules work in other religions.
I happen to think you're right, but I don't want the government deciding such things.
> It's not the government that's making this function off
> limits, it's the person's religion.
Once upon a time, a very long time ago, some citizens of Rome used to hold that a person could show they were a "good citizen" (and avoid being torn apart by lions) by sacrificing to the emperor as if he were a god. They claimed that Christians' refusal to do so was a problem with the person's religion, not with the law.
That's a way too dramatic illustration, but it's the direction that thinking leads.
I don't much care for that direction, and I say that as an atheist.