I havent been to Fire Island since I went to the wrong beach one summer. Use to be a beautiful place but I wouldnt take my children there these days. Oh go ahead and call me homophobic, but I dont want my children seeing that sort of stuff. I would rather my children be kids first and then get a glimpse of adult life.
If you drop your car keys in Cherry Grove, you'd better kick them all the way to Westhampton Beach ... :-)