What if you were really were stained by the sin of the first man, would you expect God to pretend that there was no such stain?
-A8
Tell me how I can legitimately make someone else deserving of punishment for something they didn't do.
And you didn't answer my question. Why do you think they are right? What makes their opinion better than anyone else's? They were fallible men, how do you know they didn't make a mistake?