I think a lot of conservatives are fiscal conservatives and social libertarians. Even Sean Hannity describes himself this way ... and George Bush even had a homosexual speak at the first convention.
Most people want the government out of the bedroom.
Conservatism is not the sole entity of social conservatism.
Sean Hannity a social libertarian and fiscal conservative? Insert laugh track. Hannity is a GOP loyal solidier, nothing more or less.
Rudy wants government IN your bedroom, to pry open your bedroom drawer to seize your gun.