Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: Non-Sequitur
If they are expelled then they aren't a state anymore, are they? The Constitution does not apply and they aren't entitled to representation. So show me where the Constitution forbids that.

You have a short term memory problem, don't you? We just went over this uptread. Any action to expel a state violates Article V because that act simultaneously deprives the state of representation and thus violates the Constitution.

I suspect that membership in the Senate was protected in the Constitution because the Senate was an expression of state sovereignty. As John Lansing of New York said in the ratification debates:

I believe it was undoubtedly the intention of the framers of this Constitution to make the lower house the proper, peculiar representative of the interests of the people; the Senate, of the sovereignty of the states.

347 posted on 10/17/2006 6:43:15 AM PDT by rustbucket
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 344 | View Replies ]


To: rustbucket
You have a short term memory problem, don't you? We just went over this uptread. Any action to expel a state violates Article V because that act simultaneously deprives the state of representation and thus violates the Constitution.

Yes and whenever someone points out that Article I forbids states from entering into treaties or confederations with other states without Congressional approval you all scratch your heads and say, "Golly gee whiz, if a state secedes it isn't bound by the Constitution anymore." Well, if a state is expelled then they aren't in the Union anymore, not bound by the Constitution, and not protected by it. You all are constantly quoting the 10th Amendment saying that the right to unilaterally secede is granted to the states because it is not denied by the Constitution. Well, show me where the Constitution says the states cannot join together and expel a state if they choose to do so.

354 posted on 10/17/2006 9:53:22 AM PDT by Non-Sequitur
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 347 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson