I like the idea of making that second class available only through purchase--actions (or non-actions) have consequences.
I think I would go with the service option since I know that as a youngster my family could not have paid for a second class and, sigh, money is too easy and there is always some fool who will give money.
Work though is hard and the best teacher.
McVey
Yes, I like the community service option, as long as it was real work. These kids take free school/lunch/breakfast/access to friends/etc for granted. That should cost them (and their parents).
susie