Replies

I haven't heard anything about this ruling yet, but I am 100% confident anyhow that a federal judge did not rule that NSA surveillance is unconstitutional. I am certain that what you mean is that a federal judge ruled that warrantless NSA surveillance is unconstitutional.

Unfortunately surveillance NSA-style is very often of the take-no-prisoners type. They collect it all and then search for key words and phrases. You cannot get a warrant against a single target for this type of surveillance because you looking at the full database of all the calls. Assuming that they find something of interest they look a little closer. There could easily be hundreds of thousands of such events every month (I'm guessing). Look harder and cut these down to a few thousand. Look harder and get them down to a hundred or less and off you go to the FISA court to get your warrants. If you kill the program at the top you will kill it at the bottom.