I definitely see the value in your past judgement. Obviously, we believe in God. But the scientific method, while not something to be worshipped, cannot be ignored.
The idea that God created Evolution smacks of having it both ways, but in my infinite ignorance I cannot help but see it is the most true.
As for proof, it's impossible to prove evolution, just like it's impossible to 100% verify many theories. And yes, further research and information will arise that will, at the very least, modify our perceptions of evolution. But is it the best and most explanatory theory, given the knowledge we currently have?
Yes.
'Objective' scientific method should not be ignored, but manipulated science should be. Such as a lot of GW science. Grant monies seem to somewhat control scientific ethics now.
Evolution makes sense for most all species. But, I'm not convinced 100%. You may be right as to it being impossible to prove. You'd think however, that we'd see proof in nature. There are how many gazillions of species? You'd think there'd be at least one existing link/crossover/imbetweener whatever you want to call it. Did evolution go nuts for millions of years and then just stop? An evolutionary age?