If Simcox is guilty of anything (and at this point there's nothing indicating he's guilty of anything other than the poor judgment of a novice) then I could care less if he's rode out on a rail. He and Keyes both.
I could care less about the fortunes of any individual insofar as it doesn't reflect poorly on the cause they stand for, which IMO in this case is critical.
Its not as if the certain freepers who have glommed onto this guy's problems with such relish are coming to this issue without an agenda of their own. Most have been on the open borders side for as far back as I can remember & have lost all credibility where the subject is concerned, and its clear they really think they've scored big here. Which reflects poorly on their sense of proportion & common sense, but given the way they've approached the whole borders issue thats no surprise either.
I don't know that he's broken any laws, but I think he has broken the trust of some of his followers.