Replies

Why don't you simply repost my entire reply on that thread.

As you wish.

If I recall correctly, and I may be wrong, but didn't you think that this case will hinge on the Lemon test? If so, it will be interesting to see haow he applies the Lemon test. While Jones cannot completely ignore the Lemon test, it will be interesting to see how he applies it; especially when he asked the parties to take into consideration a recent USSC decision.

I think the judge will rule very narrowly in favor of the defendants, but there won't be any leeway for actually teaching ID in the classroom. I don't see where the plaintiffs had much to gain as a practical matter once the school board modified their 'statement'. on the other hand, the ID folks will consider it quite a psychologial victory if all they win is the ability to make a simple statement that the TOE is controversial and there are other possible explanations for life.

You made a specific statement of belief that the ruling would be in favor of the defendants. I do not see how this is ambiguous.