In what way are troops, without authority to detain, without arms, an effective army?
In what way is granting amnesty by any other name effective in deterring more illegals?
Amnesty has been granted before, over and over, and always results in ever greater numbers of illegals. Insanity is expecting a different result from doing more of the same.
The minutemen were effective, they will be even moreso because they have government sanction and coordination.
In what way is granting amnesty by any other name effective in deterring more illegals?
Full amnesty is cititzenship. This is not citizenship. They will have to be signed up, or be deported. We will know who they are. They will have to go home at the end of their license. Seems like a great idea, cheap, and effective. Honestly, there is no other idea that is this good, I have never seen one given by an anti-immi this good....actually I have never seen one by them at all that had a snowball's chance in Hell of working.
So, let's give up, right? That way the anit-immis can sit back and be happy. Negative, sour, bitter......... like Grima Wormtongue.