[SAJ]

Yah. No fight intended. Besides, T-Day changes every year, and the question isn't specific that the event described occurs EVERY year.

Poorly phrased, semantically, you're quite right.

Must be July 4 then, because no President has ever had his birthday on Christmas Day (or New Year's Day, either).

Who does that make it? Coolidge?

[LexBaird]

Must be July 4 then, because no President has ever had his birthday on Christmas Day (or New Year's Day, either). Who does that make it? Coolidge?

Yes, Coolidge.

Thomas Jefferson and Adams both died on the 4th of July, 1826, the 50th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration.