My post shows our discussion, in context, along with all of the points you've ignored.
I had to read the last one all the way throough to glean the one or two sentences that were new.
Your 'new' points ignore points made previously.
Please isolate your new points and post them.
Please address the overall issue. Arguing about isolated points only serves to extend the discussion.
I have only so much time I can devote to these discussions.
All the more reason to clarify your overall objections to the FairTax, and your reasons for supporting the unconstitutional income/withholding mess.
I learned years ago that allowing myself to be baited into every point of the NRST (there are so many) I got little done.
If you want to talk to me, that is. You don't have to. I ain't anybody special.