No...I've seen no person on this thread say that we should have no immigration, period; that was the position of the know-nothings. My position on immigration is that I'm against unlimited and uncontrolled immigration, which is what we have now.
Surely you do not advocate unlimited and uncontrolled immigration, do you?
And, amazingly, that is not even remotely close to the assertion to which I was responding. Please re-read, and try again.