Romney is
Anti Second Amendment
that makes him dangerous, un-American, and a phony-conservative.
The funny part is, you're absolutely right. If these guys opened their minds for a second and actually looked into what Romney has managed to do in Massachusetts (with a liberal legislature no less), they'd have to be impressed, particularly by his economic conservatism. The guy took a liberal northeastern state and gave them a budget surplus. That's almost unheard of these days.
But, I suspect what it comes down to on this board is abortion. Abortion, abortion, abortion. Forget taxes, forget economics, forget national security, forget things that, you know, affect everyone every day. Nope, it's all about abortion. And maybe gay marriage too. Yeah, those affect us every day don't they? I don't know why people give those 2 issues priority over things that clearly matter much more. Romney is the best candidate on the things that matter. Bottom line.
Now, I give it a good 20 seconds before someone calls me a "RINO", a "liberal," a "faux conservative," or any derivative of the previous.
I hesitate to raise this, but it will be a significant factor if he runs: Romney is a member of the Mormon church. And, of course, there's nothing wrong with that. Except the media and the Dems will kill him with it. That's a fact.
In addition, Romney's position on abortion is perhaps too slippery to satisfy many conservatives.